Ask our Editors: Using a comma before ‘but’

Commas create cadence and rhythm, clauses and pauses. But it’s not always obvious where to put them, as this letter from a subscriber to our newsletter shows. Fortunately, our team of editors are here to help.

Q: May I run a quick sanity check with you please? A student asks whether it’s always necessary to use a comma when you use ‘but’ to turn a sentence.

For example:

John is generally a quiet boy, but he occasionally pipes up if anybody provokes him.

My understanding is that when the ‘but’ introduces an independent clause like this, a comma is needed.

But with this type of sentence:

Paul likes oranges but not apples…

…a comma isn’t required.

However, I want to also say to this student that there is both a technical and artistic way of looking at grammar and punctuation, so I wouldn’t rule out, for instance, the possibility of using a comma even when, from a strict grammatical standpoint, it may not be necessary.

I would love to know what you think about this answer!

Thank you,



A: Hi Sharni, the comma adds an extra pause for emphasis in this context, but isn’t necessary unless the sentence would be confusing or unwieldy without it. That sentence is a good example of where the comma is necessary, since without it you’d have a lot of words flowing together.

In the case of a shorter, simpler sentence – like the two examples in your original email – the comma isn’t essential but could be added for effect/pause, kind of like a rest in music notation. In that sentence I might have added a comma before ‘but’, but the sentence was clear enough without it.

For more detailed information you could check out our comma-specific blog post. The commas we’re talking about here fall under the ‘Subjective commas’ heading in that post, in the sense that you can use them for effect or as a signpost to help guide the reader, but they’re not mandatory.

Hope that helps!

Olivia McDowell

Senior Writer & Editor (New York)

Olivia McDowell is one of Editor Group’s editors and proofreaders. Learn more about our editing services or contact us.

Read more

Ask our editors: Hyphenating comparative and superlative compound adjectives

More Insights

Content strategyMarketingSocial mediaWriting
Social mediaThought leadershipWriting
EditingPlain EnglishVocabulary
Scroll to Top
Editor Group

The right words to help you grow sales, deliver messages and meet your compliance needs.